How thinking works

Socratic questioning, and how to use it on your own ideas

By Klevis Kokoshi, Founder of TalkGraphUpdated 9 November 20264 min read
??????Ask thenext question
In 30 seconds
  • Socratic questioning tests an idea by asking about it, not arguing for it.
  • Six kinds of question cover meaning, assumptions, evidence, other views, consequences and the question itself.
  • Alone, you avoid the questions that hurt, which is why a partner helps.

Socratic questioning is testing an idea by asking questions about it rather than arguing for it. Done well, it doesn't hand anyone an answer. It gets them to find the weak spots in their own thinking, which is why they tend to believe what they end up with.

Socrates, at least as Plato writes him, must have been maddening to talk to. He'd ask what you meant by a word, then what you meant by your answer, then whether that squared with something you'd said ten minutes earlier. People often left less sure than when they arrived, which was rather the point.

The method survived because it works. Teachers use it to get students reasoning instead of reciting. Therapists use versions of it to help people test their own assumptions. You can use it on yourself too, although that's harder than it sounds.

The 6 types of Socratic questions, with examples

Guides usually sort Socratic questions into six kinds, a split usually credited to the critical-thinking educator Richard Paul. There's no need to memorise them; it's enough to recognise the flavours and reach for the one that fits.

1. Clarifying questions

Make the idea precise before you judge it. "What exactly do you mean by growth?" "Can you give me an example?" "How does that relate to what we said earlier?"

2. Questions that probe assumptions

Find what the idea quietly rests on. "What are you taking for granted here?" "What if that weren't true?" "Is that always the case, or just this time?"

3. Questions about reasons and evidence

Ask how you know. "What's the evidence for that?" "How could we check it?" "What would change your mind?"

4. Questions about other viewpoints

Look at it from somewhere else. "How would a customer see this?" "What's the best argument against it?" "Who would disagree, and why?"

5. Questions about implications and consequences

Follow the idea forward. "If that's right, what follows?" "What happens if we're wrong?" "Where does this leave us in six months?"

6. Questions about the question

Check you're asking the right thing. "Is this the right question?" "Why does it matter?" "What would answering it actually change?"

How to do Socratic questioning, step by step

  1. Say the idea, claim or decision in one sentence.
  2. Clarify it: what do the key words actually mean, and what's an example?
  3. Dig under it: what are you assuming, and what's the evidence?
  4. Turn it around: what would someone who disagrees say?
  5. Follow it forward: if it's true, what follows, and what if it isn't?
  6. Say the idea again. If it's changed, that's the method working.

Socratic questioning for revision

Socratic questions make good revision prompts because they test understanding rather than recall of a sentence. Take a topic and ask: what does this term actually mean, in my own words? Why is it true, and how do we know? What would happen if one part changed? How does it connect to the last topic?

For example, revising the causes of the First World War: "What do I mean by the alliance system?" "What's the evidence it mattered more than militarism?" "Would war have started without the assassination?" If you can answer those out loud without notes, you understand the topic, not just the page.

Why it's hard to do alone

The trouble with questioning yourself is that you know which questions are going to hurt, and you quietly avoid them. Ask yourself what you're assuming about a new project and you'll list the assumptions you're comfortable with. The awkward one, the one the whole thing rests on, rarely makes the list.

That's why people talk ideas through with a friend, a mentor or a co-founder. Someone else doesn't know which questions to steer around.

You know which questions are going to hurt, and you quietly avoid them.

A short version to try

Next time you're stuck on a decision, say it in one sentence. Then answer three questions out loud, honestly: what am I assuming, what would change my mind, and what happens if I'm right? People tend to skip the third one, and it's often the most useful, because it makes you think past the decision to whatever comes after it.

A Socratic partner that's always there

Most AI is built to answer, which makes it a poor Socratic partner by default. TalkGraph goes the other way. As you talk, it maps what you say; when you pause, it asks you one short, open question (never more than 18 words) drawn from the last few things you said, designed to help you develop, challenge or conclude the thought. It doesn't hand you an answer. It hands the thinking back.

It won't know which questions you've been avoiding, and that's rather the point: it doesn't skip them either. Answer out loud and the map grows in the direction you hadn't considered.

TalkGraph's pop-up, A question from your Brain, during a conversation
Pause, and TalkGraph asks you one short question
TalkGraph's pop-up during revision: can you explain where the ATP actually comes from?
The kind of question a good study partner asks

Questions people ask

What are the 6 types of Socratic questions?

Clarifying questions, questions that probe assumptions, questions about reasons and evidence, questions about other viewpoints, questions about implications and consequences, and questions about the question itself.

What is an example of Socratic questioning?

Someone says "we need to grow faster". Socratic questions would be: what do you mean by grow? What are you assuming slows us down? How do you know? What's the best argument for staying the same size? What happens if we grow and it breaks something?

Can you use Socratic questioning on yourself?

Yes, though it's harder, because you tend to skip the questions that hurt. Answering out loud helps, and so does a partner or tool that asks the questions for you.

How is Socratic questioning used in revision?

Use the questions as prompts: explain the term in your own words, say why it's true and how we know, and what would change if one part were different. If you can answer without notes, you understand it.

ShareXLinkedIn
Say it out loud. See it connect.

TalkGraph maps what you say as you speak and asks you the next question. Free to try, no sign-up.

Try it freeTry an AI that asks you questions
Klevis Kokoshi
Klevis KokoshiFounder of TalkGraph

Klevis is the founder of TalkGraph, which he built and shipped solo. He has a First Class MSc in Computing and Information Systems, and writes about thinking, learning and tools that help people think rather than think for them.

LinkedIn →

Keep reading

These optional services load only after you accept. Closing the banner leaves them off. You can change your choice at any time using “Review privacy choices” on our Privacy Policy page.

Read the Privacy Policy